The bourgeoisie, wrote Heinrich Heine in 1842, was
‘obsessed by a nightmare apprehension of disaster’. An ‘instinctive dread of
communism’ sapped bourgeois commitment to liberal freedoms. Theirs was a
‘politics motivated by fear’.
Over the next 150 years, the middle classes were
repeatedly condemned by the Left as betrayers of liberty. For fear of the
masses, the bourgeoisie colluded with the strong-armed state. Failure of the
liberal revolutions in 1848, the rise of authoritarian nationalism from the
1860s, fascist victories in the first half of the twentieth-century, and brutal
repression of national liberation movements throughout the Cold War – all these
fateful disasters the Left blamed squarely on bourgeois timidity and treachery.
For their part, conservatives accused the insidious Left. They insisted that leftist
demagogues and fanatics exploited the desperation of the poor to subvert
liberal revolutions, leading to anarchy and tyranny.
With the collapse of Communism, bourgeois liberty once
again became a crusading force. The armed forces of NATO became instruments of
‘regime change’, seeking to destroy dictatorship and to build free-market
democracies. President George W. Bush boasted the invasion of Iraq in 2003 as a
‘watershed event in the global democratic revolution’. Neoconservatives hailed
the bourgeoisie as the truly universal class which, in emancipating itself,
emancipates all society. Such middle class triumphalism was not to last. The
debacle in Iraq and the Great Recession from 2008 revealed all too clearly that
hubris still invites nemesis.
Bourgeois Liberty and the Politics of Fear uncovers this
remarkable story, and the fierce debates it occasioned. It takes in a span from
the seventeenth century to the twenty-first, covering a wide range of countries
and thinkers. Strikingly original, and broad in its scope, it presents a clear
set of arguments that shed new light on the creation of our modern world.
No comments:
Post a Comment